Editor, the Commercial:
The Military Officers Association of America (MOAA) and 24 other military and veterans organizations filed a brief in the United States Supreme Court seeking to overturn an appellate court decision finding the Stolen Valor Act unconstitutional. The Stolen Valor Act makes it a crime for individuals to falsely claim they have been awarded any military decoration or medal authorized by Congress for the Armed Forces. To falsely claim receipt of the Medal of Honor is the highest affront one can make to every man and women who ever served in a combat zone.
MOAA’s brief argues the case is not about free speech, but about individuals like Alvarez stealing the goodwill and prestige associated with American military awards for their own benefit. Military veterans earn awards through service, sacrifice and valor. MOAA believes it is well within Congress’ power to prevent individuals from falsely claiming for themselves the goodwill and acclaim associated with hard-earned military awards and honors.
There have been numerous cases of an individual falsely claiming they or a child had a serious medical condition, then profiting from the ensuing charity. When found out, they go to jail.
“It is vitally important to preserve the integrity of the system recognizing military valor and the sacrifices our service members make for their country,” MOAA President Vice Adm. Norb Ryan (USN-Ret) said. “No one should be allowed to steal what our veterans have rightfully earned through their service and sacrifice.”
Independent reporting for Pine Bluff & Jefferson County since 1879.
Yelling “fire” in a crowded theater, saying “bomb” on an airliner, or “stick up” in a bank is not free speech. This is no difference. I strongly suspect the Commercial editorial writer claiming this repugnant act was “free speech” never had the privilege of serving with Medal of Honor recipients.
CW2 Stu Soffer, US Army-Retired
SE Arkansas Chapter MOAA
White Hall